As you know from our last post, we’re in the midst of a 3-part series on empowerment evaluation. In our prior installment we introduced the basics of empowerment evaluation providing you with some of the key concepts and a big picture overview. For this post we’d like to focus a little more on one of the key components of the theory, which is client control over the evaluation. The role of the evaluator in an empowerment evaluation is to encourage clients to collaborate, communicate, and be involved in the process of program improvement. Evaluators are the facilitators or coaches to the program improvement process where the client is in control. This a key difference from other theories or approaches to evaluation where the evaluator is in control of the process.
What? The client is in control, can that be right? --- Yes!
However, evaluators would never just hand over the reins to
clients without providing them with the necessary components for an effective and credible evaluation. The most traditional concept of evaluation typically means placing a value
judgment of the merit and worth of a program, but in empowerment evaluation the
context for the evaluation is different, as the clients are heavily involved.
Rather than assessing the value or impact of a program, empowerment evaluation focuses
on program improvement.
Where should one start with empowerment evaluation?
Because empowerment evaluation calls for huge investments of
time and energy from the clients, it can be difficult to know how to begin.
David Fetterman, the father of the empowerment evaluation, suggests several
steps to ensure that clients are prepared for the extensive process of
illumination and understanding that leads to the program improvement brought by
empowerment evaluation. The four steps for clients that can help facilitate the
learning process are as follows:
1) Taking Stock: With the help of the evaluator,
begin to determine where the program currently stands. Discussions should
include requisite program resources and the ultimate impact of the program.
2) Establish Goals: Discuss program
improvement with the coach (evaluator) and community. Define exactly what needs
to be better and where program staff and others in the community want the
program to be in the future.
3) Develop Strategies: Converse with staff
members about the potential challenges that could arise during the evaluation process
and establish clear strategies to ensure a successful evaluation is implemented
and desired outcomes are achieved.
4) Select Evidence: Determine outcomes and
indicators to reach the program improvement goals established in step 2. Ask
yourself “How will I reach my goals and objectives? How will I measure success
of accomplishing goals?”
Alright, we’ve highlighted some important aspects of
empowerment evaluation and steps to begin the process but there is so much more
information about empowerment evaluation out there.
Are you further intrigued about empowerment evaluation? Then
be sure to look for our last blog post in this empowerment evaluation series
coming soon, where we will discuss in which contexts and for whom empowerment
evaluation is a good fit.
You can also find more information about empowerment
evaluation by clicking on these links:
David Fetterman’s Empowerment Evaluation blog: http://eevaluation.blogspot.com.au/?view=magazine
Better Evaluation website with a plethora of resources on
empowerment evaluation: http://betterevaluation.org/plan/approach/empowerment_evaluation
Sources:
Fetterman, D. M.
(1996). Empowerment evaluation in theory. The
Evaluation Exchange, 2(2), n.p. Retrieved from website: http://www.hfrp.org/evaluation/the-evaluation-exchange/issue-archive/family-resource-centers/empowerment-evaluation-in-theory
Fetterman, D. M.,
Rodriquez-Campos, L., Wandersman, A., & Goldfarb O’Sullivan, R. (2014).
Collaborative, participatory, and empowerment evaluation: Building a strong
conceptual foundation for stakeholder involvement approaches to evaluation (a
response to Cousins, Whitmore, and Shulha, 2013). American Journal of Evaluation, 35(1), 144-148. doi:
10.1177/1098214013509875.
Sherriff, B.,
& Porter, S. (n.d.). An introduction to empowerment evaluation: Teaching
materials. Retrieved from website: http://www.mrc.ac.za/crime/evaluation.pdf
No comments:
Post a Comment